Glenn Reynolds and the K-12 Implosion - The Objective Standard

In The K-12 Implosion, Glenn Reynolds makes a commonsense argument that government-run schools are in a bubble—a bubble that is ready to pop.

He notes, for example, that the government has spent ever-increasing amounts of money on K-12 education but can show for it no positive returns, only negative ones—and many at that. He observes that near-bankrupt state and local governments cannot afford to do this forever. And, on these (and related) grounds, invoking Stein’s Law, he predicts that they won’t.

The book is short in length—just forty-eight pages—but not on substance. Reynolds addresses a wide range of issues from the invalid purpose of government-run schools to what a death spiral for them could look like, and he does so both clearly and calmly.

Unfortunately, despite the horrible record of government-run schools, Reynolds does not call for their abolition and the full privatization of education. He does not ask readers to wage war on the government-run school system. In this regard, he simply notes that more and more parents are taking their kids out of these war zones and saying why they’re doing so and what alternatives they’re opting for.

This last may be the most influential part of the book. Many people know, at least on some level, that government-run schools are bad, but too few are aware of the extent of the available and good alternatives. Reynolds highlights some of these, including, for instance, Khan Academy; and in doing so he speaks not just as a commentator, but as the proud parent of a daughter who took full advantage of the opportunities offered by a flexible, individualized, online, and fully private education.

Of course, bubbles often expand or persist longer than expected, but the reasoning behind Reynolds prediction of a coming implosion is sound. Herb Stein after all was right when he said that something that can’t go on forever, won’t. But even the implosion of government-run schools won’t be the end of them unless Americans call for their end. As long as Americans are willing to fund government-run schools, these real-life nightmares will continue, even if in an imploded form.

Like this post? Join our mailing list to receive our weekly digest. And for in-depth commentary from an Objectivist perspective, subscribe to our quarterly journal, The Objective Standard.


Return to Top

Pin It on Pinterest